Fair enough - you’re right that LLMs and brains work very differently under the hood. But the point isn’t about the mechanism; it’s about the illusion of agency. When you say you “agree” that feeling emerges from neural processes you’re not consciously controlling - just like an LLM’s response emerges from its training and inputs. Neither system “chooses” in a philosophical sense; both produce outputs shaped by prior data. So while the architectures differ wildly, the claim that only humans can truly “agree” might say more about how we interpret our own cognition than about what’s actually happening.
1 Like
